タイトル |
-
en
A Comparison of Tobacco Policy in the UK and Japan : If the Scientific Evidence is Identical, Why is There a Major Difference in Policy?
|
作成者 |
|
アクセス権 |
open access |
権利情報 |
-
en
This is an Accepted Manuscript of an article published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of comparative policy analysis on 2017-5-16, available online: http://www.tandfonline.com/10.1080/13876988.2017.1323439
|
主題 |
-
Other
en
comparative policy
-
Other
en
UK
-
Other
en
Japan
-
Other
en
tobacco control
-
Other
en
policy environments
-
Other
en
multiple streams approach
-
Other
en
evidence-based policy making
-
NDC
300
|
内容注記 |
-
Abstract
en
Tobacco policy in the UK and Japan has diverged markedly. In the 1980s, both countries oversaw regimes with minimal economic and regulatory policies. Now the UK has become one of the most, and Japan one of the least, controlled (advanced industrial) states. These developments are puzzling to public health scholars who give primary explanatory weight to scientific evidence and a vague notion of political will, because policy makers possessed the same evidence on the harms of tobacco, and made the same international commitment to comprehensive tobacco control. Instead, we identify the role of a mutually reinforcing dynamic in policy environments, facilitating policy change in the UK but not Japan: policy makers accepted the scientific evidence, framed tobacco as a public health epidemic, placed health departments at the heart of policy, formed networks with public health groups and excluded tobacco companies, and accentuated socio-economic conditions supportive of tobacco control. This dynamic helps explain why the UK became more likely to select each tobacco policy control instrument during a series of windows of opportunity. Such analysis, generated by policy theory, is crucial to contemporary science/practitioner debates on the politics of evidence-based policy making: the evidence does not speak for itself, and practitioners need to know how to use it effectively in policy environments.
|
出版者 |
en
Taylor & Francis
|
日付 |
|
言語 |
|
資源タイプ |
journal article |
出版タイプ |
AM |
資源識別子 |
HDL
http://hdl.handle.net/2115/71983
|
関連 |
-
isVersionOf
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1080/13876988.2017.1323439
|
収録誌情報 |
-
-
en
Journal of comparative policy analysis
-
巻20
号3
開始ページ253
終了ページ268
|
ファイル |
|
コンテンツ更新日時 |
2023-07-26 |